Welcome to Leoforce!
Home Resources Guides A comprehensive guide to employee reference checks and background checks in the hiring process

A comprehensive guide to employee reference checks and background checks in the hiring process

A Comprehensive Guide to Employee Reference Checks and Background Checks in the Hiring Process

In today’s competitive job market, employers rely on various methods to evaluate and assess potential job applicants. One crucial aspect of the hiring process is conducting employee reference checks and background checks. This comprehensive guide aims to provide job applicants with a detailed understanding of the purpose of reference checks and unveil some industry secrets regarding background checks and the information they can reveal about applicants. Whether you are a job seeker or an HR professional, understanding these practices will help you navigate the hiring process effectively and by familiarizing yourself with these processes, you can better prepare for job interviews and increase your chances of securing a desirable position.

Understanding Employee Reference Checks

Reference checks are a process conducted by employers to gather information about a job applicant from individuals who have had direct professional or personal interactions with the applicant in the past. This involves contacting individuals who have worked with the job applicant in the past to gather insights into their work performance, skills, and character.

The purpose of reference checks is to verify the applicant’s qualifications, skills, work experience, and character, as well as to gain additional perspectives on their capabilities for the job they have applied for.

The reference check is typically conducted by the hiring manager, human resources personnel, or a designated representative within the organization. Sometimes, organizations employ third-party agencies specializing in background checks in the process. This or these person(s) contacts the references provided by the applicant and engages in a conversation or sends a questionnaire to gather relevant information. The references can include former supervisors, colleagues, clients, or other individuals who have worked closely with the applicant.

There are two primary types of reference checks

  1. Professional References: These references are individuals who have directly supervised or worked alongside the applicant in a professional capacity. They can provide insights into the applicant’s job performance, work ethic, skills, and overall professional conduct that covers their behavior and team synergy.
  2. Personal References: Personal references are individuals who can vouch for the applicant’s character, integrity, and personal qualities. They may include friends, mentors, or other individuals who have known the applicant in a non-professional context. Family is usually not permitted to be provided as a reference to avoid the issue of bias.

The importance of reference checks in the hiring process cannot be overstated. Reference checks offer employers a more comprehensive understanding of an applicant’s abilities, work ethic, and compatibility with the company culture. While verifying and validating an applicant’s skills and experiences, they are also able to gauge the character of the applicant and if they would be a cultural fit in the organization. They help employers make informed decisions, mitigate hiring risks, and ensure the applicant is the right fit for the role and the organization.

When employers conduct reference checks, they are seeking valuable insights into a job applicant’s qualifications, work experience, skills, and character. These checks serve as a way for employers to validate the claims made by the applicant in their resume and interviews.

Here are some specific aspects that employers seek in reference checks

  1. Confirmation of Qualifications: Employers want to ensure that the applicant possesses the necessary qualifications and skills for the role. They may ask references about the applicant’s educational background, certifications, specialized training, or any other relevant qualifications.
  2. Verification of Work History: Employers want to confirm the accuracy of the applicant’s work history. They may ask references about the positions the applicant held, dates of employment, job responsibilities, and any notable achievements or promotions.
  3. Assessment of Work Performance: Employers are interested in evaluating the applicant’s performance in previous roles. They may ask references about the quality of the applicant’s work, their ability to meet deadlines, their attention to detail, and their overall work ethic. Employers may also inquire about the applicant’s ability to work independently or as part of a team.
  4. Insights into Interpersonal Skills: Interpersonal skills are crucial in most workplaces. Employers may ask references about the applicant’s communication skills, ability to collaborate with others, conflict resolution abilities, and overall professional demeanor.
  5. Cultural Fit: Employers want to assess whether the applicant will fit well within the company culture. They may inquire about the applicant’s adaptability, attitude towards teamwork, problem-solving approach, and alignment with the organization’s values and mission.
  6. Strengths and Weaknesses: References are often asked about the applicant’s strengths and weaknesses. Employers want to gain a comprehensive understanding of the applicant’s abilities and areas for improvement. This helps them determine how the applicant’s skills align with the requirements of the position.
  7. Reliability and Dependability: Employers seek to gauge the applicant’s reliability and dependability. They may ask references about the applicant’s punctuality, attendance, ability to handle pressure, and willingness to take initiative.
  8. Leadership and Management Potential: If the role involves leadership or management responsibilities, employers may inquire about the applicant’s leadership skills, ability to motivate and inspire others, and their potential for growth in a managerial role.
  9. Overall Recommendation: Employers often ask references for their overall recommendation regarding the applicant’s suitability for the position. This helps them assess the reference’s level of confidence in the applicant and make a more informed hiring decision.

It’s important to note that employers understand that references may have certain limitations due to their professional relationship with the applicant. It is also necessary to keep in mind that references may have their biases or may not be able to provide comprehensive information due to legal or organizational constraints. However, when conducted diligently, reference checks provide valuable insights that complement the overall assessment of an applicant’s suitability for a job position. Nevertheless, the information provided by references plays a significant role in shaping the employer’s perception of the applicant’s qualifications and suitability for the role.

Common Myths of Background Checks

Background checks involve a thorough investigation of an applicant’s personal, educational, and professional history. The purpose is to validate the information provided by the applicant, assess their integrity, and ensure they meet the company’s standards and legal requirements.

Some common types of background checks

  1. Employment History Verification: Confirming the accuracy of job titles, dates of employment, responsibilities, and reasons for leaving.
  2. Education Verification: Verifying educational degrees, certifications, and institutions attended.
  3. Criminal Record Check: Assessing if the applicant has any criminal convictions or records.
  4. Credit History Check: Examining the applicant’s creditworthiness, especially for positions involving financial responsibility.
  5. Professional License Verification: Validating the applicant’s professional licenses and certifications, if relevant.

Other aspects of background checks

  • Comprehensive Information: Background checks can reveal a wide range of information about job applicants, including criminal records, employment history, education verification, credit history, professional licenses, and social media presence. These checks aim to provide a holistic view of the applicant’s background and help employers make informed hiring decisions.
  • Third-Party Services: Many employers outsource background checks to specialized third-party companies that have access to extensive databases and resources. These companies are skilled in conducting thorough investigations and ensuring compliance with legal requirements.
  • Social Media Screening: Employers often review an applicant’s social media profiles as part of background checks. Evaluating the applicant’s online presence and activities is essential to assess their professionalism and potential red flags that may be a point of conflict for the organization in the future especially if they are being hired for a c-suite position. Social media screening provides additional insights into an applicant’s behavior, values, and overall online presence. It is essential for applicants to manage their social media profiles thoughtfully and ensure they align with their professional image.
  • International Background Checks: Background checks can differ significantly across countries due to variations in data privacy laws, access to information, and cultural considerations. Employers operating globally may face challenges when conducting background checks in different jurisdictions. They conduct these checks to ensure that they are not wanted on felony or other charges that may become an issue in the future should the applicant travel to a country where they are wanted on some charges.

Confidentiality and Legal Considerations of these checks

Employers must follow legal requirements and guidelines when conducting background checks to protect applicant privacy. The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) in the United States and similar regulations in other countries outline the rights of applicants and establish guidelines for obtaining and using background information. Some points to note on the legality and admissibility of background checks

  • Consent and Disclosure: With the recent challenges in USA, EU and Asia, the need for consent and the use of data responsibly has become paramount in the business world. Employers have no choice but to first obtain the applicant’s written consent before conducting a background check. They should also provide clear disclosure about the type of information being sought and how it will be used and how it will be stored.
  • Compliance with Laws: Background checks must comply with local, state, and federal laws. These laws may vary and can include restrictions on what information can be collected, how it can be used, and the applicant’s rights to access and dispute the information. Some laws from the applicant’s country of origin may take precedence over the local law where the applicant currently resides or in seeking employment at.
  • Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA): In the United States, the FCRA governs background checks conducted by third-party consumer reporting agencies. It requires employers to follow specific procedures, such as providing pre-adverse action notices, allowing applicants to dispute inaccurate information, and providing adverse action notices if employment decisions are made based on the background check.
  • Ban the Box: Some jurisdictions have also implemented “ban the box” laws that restrict employers from asking about an applicant’s criminal history in the initial stages of the application process. These laws aim to provide fair opportunities for individuals with criminal records to compete for employment.

How to make background checks a hassle-free process?

By being proactive, transparent, and aware of their rights, applicants can navigate the background check process more effectively and increase their chances of a favorable outcome.

  • Provide Accurate Information: It is essential for applicants to ensure the information provided on their resumes, applications, and references is accurate and up to date. Any discrepancies discovered during the background check process can raise concerns. Your resume must give accurate information to avoid discrepancies during the reference and background check process.
  • Be Transparent and Proactive: If there are potential red flags in the applicant’s background, it is advisable to address them proactively during the application process. Providing explanations or context for any issues can help mitigate concerns and demonstrate personal growth or improvement.
  • Review Online Presence: Applicants should review their online presence, including social media profiles, to ensure they align with their professional image. Adjust privacy settings if necessary and remove any inappropriate content that could potentially impact the hiring decision.
  • Know Your Rights: Applicants should familiarize themselves with the laws and regulations related to background checks in their jurisdiction. Understanding their rights regarding consent, disclosure, and the use of information can help applicants navigate the process effectively.
  • Maintain Professional References: Having strong and supportive professional references can positively impact the background check process. Applicants should cultivate relationships with former supervisors or colleagues who can provide positive and accurate information about their skills and work performance. When the time comes to ask them to stand as a reference, inform your professional references in advance, seeking their permission and reminding them of your past work together.
  • Prepare for interview questions: Anticipate questions related to your past experiences, work performance, and character traits based on the information your references might provide. If you anticipate concerns or discrepancies in your background that could be red flags, be prepared to provide context or explanations during the interview.

The recent shift to hybrid work models and the recognition of the mental health effects of the pandemic, has made the process of background checks to undergo some changes. In the new age of hiring trends, there is added emphasis to identify an applicant’s technology and cybersecurity awareness along with their digital literacy. Desk jobs are fast becoming remote jobs and applicants are expected to be on-par with the job needs of adapting to technology.

Mental health too has come into focus with many background checks now expanding into medical history, understanding the work-life balance and flexibility. Applicants should consider discussing their ability to manage remote work, maintain boundaries, and prioritize self-care during the interview or reference check process. This can demonstrate their adaptability and resilience in the face of evolving work environments.

Applicants should be aware of the evolving hiring practices, emphasize their adaptability to hybrid work environments, highlight relevant soft skills, and be mindful of the impact of the pandemic on mental health. By understanding and effectively navigating these changes, applicants can position themselves as strong candidates in the new way of hiring practices. With many businesses opting for virtual hiring practices and video screening, it is highly imperative that applicants are using clear and open communication with employers is crucial during the background check process. Applicants should be transparent about any potential challenges they faced during the pandemic and how they have managed or overcome them rather than it being flagged in a background check.

Overall, employee reference checks and background checks are essential components of the hiring process, enabling employers to make informed decisions about potential job applicants. By understanding the purpose and significance of these checks, job seekers can proactively prepare themselves, ensure accuracy in their application materials, and present themselves in the best possible light during interviews. Honest and proactive communication and self-awareness are key when it comes to reference checks and background checks and can help build trust and demonstrate resilience.


What is the purpose of employee reference checks?

Employee reference checks serve to verify qualifications, assess work performance, evaluate interpersonal skills, determine cultural fit, and make informed hiring decisions.

Who conducts reference checks in the hiring process?

Reference checks are typically conducted by the hiring manager, human resources personnel, or designated representatives within the organization. In some cases, third-party agencies specializing in background checks may be involved.

What information do employers seek during reference checks?

Employers seek confirmation of qualifications, verification of work history, assessment of work performance, insights into interpersonal skills, evaluation of cultural fit, understanding of strengths and weaknesses, assessment of reliability and dependability, evaluation of leadership and management potential, and overall recommendations.

What are the common types of background checks conducted by employers?

Common types of background checks include employment history verification, education verification, criminal record checks, credit history checks, and professional license verification.

How can applicants ensure a hassle-free background check process?

Applicants can make the background check process hassle-free by providing accurate information, being transparent and proactive, reviewing their online presence, knowing their rights, maintaining professional references, and preparing for interview questions.

Find more compatible candidates with Talent Intelligence.

Discover how Arya goes beyond conventional AI recruiting